The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming

They promised you the world. Then they broke your ****ing heart.
7/29/2009 9:10 AM | 36 Comments | Page 1 of 2

Scott Jones
Scott Jones
Status: Coffee makes me feel 4-percent sexier.
(Contributors: John Teti, Evan Narcisse)

From its inception -- [robotic voice] "WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF COMPUTER GAMES!" -- this industry has always promised to deliver the future. In the never-ending quest to be the first to deliver a day-after-tomorrow experience, it's no surprise that more than a few of these promises turned out to be as hollow as a stuffed animal you won at a state fair. Sure, it looks cute and all, but once you get it home, the seams start to show, sawdust begins leaking everywhere, and you're left wondering what you've "won" after all.

The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
11. Wii MotionPlus attachment (2009)

Sure, it's better. But is it $20 worth of better? At this point, no. We've swung our way through three games that have been optimized for the Wii MotionPlus, including Wii Sports Resort, which was designed to show what the device can really do. Our highly scientific results: a few degrees shy of negligible.


The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
10. Gizmondo (2005)

This hideous $400 game-playing GPS device stands as one of gaming's all-time greatest piles of sh*t. Only eight of the 14 promised games for the unit were ever released. And by February of the following year, sales were so pathetic that it was mercifully taken out behind the virtual woodshed and shot to death.


The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
9. Pac-Man on the Atari 2600 (1982)

This cartridge promised an experience that would approximate what we were paying 25 cents for at the time in arcades. We all thought, "No way!" What we eventually got was a blue-and-yellow maze populated with one ghost that appeared to split into four ghosts at various intervals, and a circular object -- i.e., the Pac-Man -- that was about as easy to control as a car with wheels that are made entirely out of banana peels and Vaseline.


The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
8. The Phantom (2002)

The Phantom promised on-demand PC games not unlike what OnLive is promising to deliver. But it turned out to be an elaborate hoax; one that's rivaled, to this day, only by the inglorious Piltdown Man. Viva la Piltdown Man! Viva!


The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
7. PSP Connect/rearview mirror capability for racing games (2007)

Sony promised that the PSP could someday be used with the PlayStation 3 as a rearview mirror in racing games. Formula One Championship Edition was actually slated to include this capability, but at the last second, it was axed. It seems someone at Sony realized, at the 11th hour, that this was a totally stupid, uninteresting, wasteful idea.


The 11 Biggest Frauds in Gaming
6. VMU "Games" (Dreamcast; 1999)

The little memory unit with the LCD screen certainly was nifty. (We still fondly recall the satisfying "click" it made when you popped it into the controller.) But the unit also purported to be a portable game-playing device. The idea was a good one. But the execution? Very bad. Terrible, even. These games are fun only if mowing the lawn or cracking walnuts absolutely delights you.


« Prev  1  2  Next »  

Share This

  • Stumbleupon Share Button
  • Delicious Share Button
  • Reddit Share Button
  • Slashdot Share Button
  • Fark Share Button
  • Yahoo Buzz Share Button

Comments

  • girlgamer21
    girlgamer21

    9/18/2009 1:55:06 PM

    @Reality Check:

    wow thats a bit harsh

    Reply »
  • Grimreaper2191
    Grimreaper2191

    8/12/2009 1:54:54 PM

    There was the promise of live streaming video from video games, now it's ture but it's taken some time to get there. At livestreaming www.livestream.com, I use it, look up my channel @ grimreaper2191

    Reply »
  • indefinable
    indefinable

    8/3/2009 8:44:35 PM

    1) Fable/BC (anything with the crazy frothing man)
    2) TFLO (pulled because micorsoft failed to understand how long an MMORPG goes through development)
    3) Halo 2 (where were the ninja's on fire)
    4) anything that states "next generation" (xbox, ps2, gamecube era)
    5) FF 10 and MGS 2 (so much they could have done with the PS2 versions of these games, both include the worst lead characters in ANY game)
    6) Atari Jaguar
    7) The Game Gear TV Tuner
    8) Ultima IX: Ascension (the last one, if you haven't completed it.. he dies at the end, turns out he was the good side, the bad guy was the bad side.. both had to die to save the world. the pirate chick was pissed, the free tarot cards in the box were nice though)
    9) Nintendo's ROB
    10) any new MMORPG (tabula rasa - dead, DDO - now DDU and f2p, etc etc, all promised, none delivered at launch)

    8) Power Glove
    9)

    Reply »
  • BraidScott
    BraidScott

    8/3/2009 7:07:37 PM

    Did you actually write this? Mode 7 a fraud? Used in such fraudulent games as Mario RPG, Pilotwings, F-Zero, and many others to lesser degrees. The technology itself worked just fine, and you're calling it a fraud because developers used it too much?

    You should probably define what your rules are for "fraud" before you start grabbing random technologies and throwing them on a list. The WiiMotion Plus? It's been out for less than 2 months! What the hell are you doing? You put out a REVIEW at this point, not an accusation about it being a fraud (not that I'm trying to defend its technology); why not put Project Natal on your list?

    Wow... just wow...

    Reply »
  • ScottJones
    Game Trust Member
    ScottJones (Game Trust Writer)

    8/3/2009 12:49:36 PM

    @Reality Check:

    Dad? Is that you?

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • RyanKuo
    Game Trust Member
    RyanKuo (Game Trust Writer)

    8/3/2009 11:07:23 AM

    @mk1601:

    Rise of the Robots WAS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply »
  • johnteti
    Game Trust Member
    johnteti (Game Trust Writer)

    8/2/2009 10:02:26 PM

    @Reality Check:

    You certainly showed the "obvious troll" who's boss by posting an insane, outlandishly enraged comment in response! Trolls hate that!

    Reply »
  • Reality Check
    Reality Check

    8/2/2009 9:16:06 PM

    Obvious troll is obvious.

    Hey, at least you can pretend to be famous for a few minutes, right? Except for the fact that everyone outside of this website seems to think you are a complete moron. I'm not going to waste my time tearing this abomination of an "article" apart, just go on Kotaku (http://tinyurl.com/l5f282), Digg (http://tinyurl.com/l8cjzv), or even this very website for that matter and read the comments. Not that you would, of course, because that would require effort, something this article shows you are incapable of.
    Don't waste your time with a jovial response, I already have seen enough morons on the internet resort to emoticons and insults when they have no real grasp of the English language. Was it worth it, Scottyboy? Was it worth the small shred of dignity you had left after making nothing of yourself? Perhaps you are just a bitter man, left a fragmented and empty shell after no magazine wanted to hire you once they saw how terrible your witting is; but hey, writing about video games for Playboy, Sports Illustrated for Kids and the ilk is really cool. I mean seriously, those are magazines known for their video game prowess, am I right?

    A bitter man with a neck beard. Because those are cool.
    No hard feelings, you pathetic scumbag.
    ;-)

    Reply »
  • jellishot
    jellishot

    8/2/2009 10:58:31 AM

    My list:

    11. http://www.crispygamer.com/features/2009-07-29/the-11-biggest-frauds-in-gaming.aspx

    10. Mad Catz accessories that aren't the Street Fighter TE fight stick.

    9. The XBOX 360 hard drive. 150 bucks for 120 gigs? Seriously?

    8. Killzone 2: the trailer

    7. Why am I playing as a blond chick in MGS2?

    6. How much trade in credit will I get for this game? And you're going to sell it for HOW MUCH???

    5. Chrono Trigger DS. It's good and all, but it should be $7 on Virtual Console. Period.

    4. Third party game trailers that say "Only on PS3". Except Haze.

    3. Haze.

    2. Any movie based on a video game.

    1. Bobby Kotick-he's obviously Satan disguised as a human.

    Reply »
  • Rhode
    Rhode

    8/2/2009 9:31:13 AM

    I find it strange that you would have the N64 Expansion Pack that high on your list. It came bundled with some AAA titles and allowed you to play perhaps the top 3 games of the console: Donkey Kong 64, Perfect Dark and LoZ: Majora's Mask (which you completely forgot). Well worth the investment considering that the N64 as a platform did not really have a mass of great games to choose from.

    The Transfer Pack would have been a better peripheral to include in the list. Swapping Pokemon and Mario Golf characters or playing GB on the TV, srsly? Even the amount of games supported was far lower than what the EP supported.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • Bulk Slash
    Bulk Slash

    8/2/2009 7:53:04 AM

    You put Mode 7 in the list? Fail.

    Reply »
  • ScottJones
    Game Trust Member
    ScottJones (Game Trust Writer)

    8/1/2009 11:12:06 AM

    @mk1601:

    You sound like a very nice and very sane person. Come back and see us again sometime! Hugs. -Scott Jones

    Reply »
  • HaroldGoldberg
    Game Trust Member
    HaroldGoldberg (Game Trust Writer)

    8/1/2009 10:19:44 AM

    i agree with the prophet. it wouldn't be so bad if people who quoted pachter came back and took him to task when they found him to be wrong. is that laziness or fear on the parts of game writers? probably both. bold piece, scott.

    Reply »
  • mk1601
    mk1601

    7/31/2009 11:00:41 PM

    This is an awful article. If you have to do a "here are a bunch of things and the one thing everyone remembers about each" piece, at least pick a coherent enough set of examples that you don't have to make stuff up for half of them to fit your theme.

    It seems you can't move for articles describing Wii Motion Plus as a fraud... no, wait, that's the thing that costs peanuts and people are buying the shit out of, isn't it? Hardly a "betrayal" on the scale of, well, Spore for one. Or Black & White. Or Rise of the Robots. Or Resident Evil 5. Or Perfect Dark Pre-Alpha... I mean, Zero.

    You came tantalisingly close to a point in mentioning Mode 7, seeing as the SNES games which made the most worthwhile use of 3D (e.g. Super Mario Kart) had DSP chips built into the carts.

    The Pachter thing I don't even know what you're trying to say, beyond this is an analyst whose name you've read. Maybe you can follow up with some "kerrazy" Ken Kutaragi quotes out of context, really reach for the journalistic high bar.

    Reply »
  • GusMastrapa
    Game Trust Member
    GusMastrapa (Game Trust Writer)

    7/31/2009 11:01:45 AM

    @Vangar:

    I do that with my Rock Band 2 songs all the time.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • Vangar
    Vangar

    7/31/2009 2:53:58 AM

    @johnteti:

    Try and put your Xbox 360 hard drive into another Xbox and attempt to play your downloaded content / Rockband 2 songs.

    What a rip.

    Reply »
  • SykoTavo
    SykoTavo

    7/30/2009 5:43:37 PM

    You forgot Spore.

    They promised us a mature sandbox game based on the science of evolution, instead they gave us 4 crappy minigames that poorly imitate different game genres and one massively annoying space game.

    Reply »
  • Sendai
    Sendai

    7/30/2009 5:11:34 PM

    "This list sucks, you forgot a few very big ones: Starcraft: Ghost, Warcraft: Lord of the Clans and the biggest of the two on my list, Duke Nukem Forever."

    Um, no. Those weren't technically frauds since they never actually come out. The Phantom game console never actually came out either but the company and various CEOs and are under fraud investigation for fleecing money from investors.

    Reply »
  • johnteti
    Game Trust Member
    johnteti (Game Trust Writer)

    7/30/2009 3:52:16 PM

    I actually agree with Vangar. I think it is stupid that I can't play Tetris on other systems' memory cards. My PS2 memory cards just sit there and retain data like little non-game-playing jerks. And just the other day, I pulled out my Xbox 360 hard drive to play a nice game of Dig Dug, and instead I got nothing. Why? Because Microsoft is a dumb.

    Reply »
  • GusMastrapa
    Game Trust Member
    GusMastrapa (Game Trust Writer)

    7/30/2009 3:04:58 PM

    @Vangar:

    Dugg to annoy Vangar.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • Vangar
    Vangar

    7/30/2009 2:19:47 PM

    @ScottJones:

    It still wouldn't be as annoying as this list on Digg.

    Reply »
  • Biblioteqa
    Biblioteqa

    7/30/2009 1:23:56 PM

    @ScottJones:

    Reply »
  • ScottJones
    Game Trust Member
    ScottJones (Game Trust Writer)

    7/30/2009 12:24:52 PM

    @Vangar:

    You and Mangoon should make an annoying baby together.

    :)

    Reply »
  • Vangar
    Vangar

    7/30/2009 10:27:31 AM

    I agree with Mangoon, This list doesn't hit on the True failures.

    Did you try Tetris or etch a sketch on the VMU ? They were good games that worked on the memory card! What other system has Tetris on the memory card? None? I thought so.

    What other home console system at the time had scalable sprites? (System 7?) Oh, none. Mario Kart on SNES uses it for the racetrack, and for its time, was pretty amazing. That mode 7 made Mario Kart man, and how many sequels did that get?

    The Gameboy Camera, if you remember, had a whole host of games where you could place your face into the main character, which was hilarious. You could do a frame by frame animation on there too. The camera has a small cult following for it's poor quality too.

    Here's a huge fraud people seem to forget - Halo 2's game trailers before release, promising huge scale war on earth. Go look up the trailers if people have forgotten already.

    Reply »
  • ScottJones
    Game Trust Member
    ScottJones (Game Trust Writer)

    7/30/2009 10:09:57 AM

    @Mudbeed:

    Mudbeed: It's official: Mode-7 was lame.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • ScottJones
    Game Trust Member
    ScottJones (Game Trust Writer)

    7/30/2009 10:08:54 AM

    @Mangoon:

    Mangoon: This list could have been 50 items long, and could have satisfied everyone--EVEN YOU AND YOUR INCREDIBLY HIGH STANDARDS--but it was mainly designed as a vehicle to call out the Wii Motion Plus. That thing is the biggest disappointment of 2009 so far. Like boobs on a bull or Tony Danza on stage, it's useless.

    Reply »
  • BugMeNot
    BugMeNot

    7/30/2009 8:02:17 AM

    I'm surprised that Peter Molyneux didn't make it into this list.

    Reply »
  • ernesto42
    ernesto42

    7/30/2009 4:51:59 AM

    And you could add this website : http://www.goldiesgames.com to the list

    Reply »
  • Mangoon
    Mangoon

    7/30/2009 12:17:49 AM

    of the three on my list*

    Reply »
  • Mangoon
    Mangoon

    7/30/2009 12:16:32 AM

    This list sucks, you forgot a few very big ones: Starcraft: Ghost, Warcraft: Lord of the Clans and the biggest of the two on my list, Duke Nukem Forever.

    And your bullsh!t ramblings about the N64 expansion pack are phail and anybody could tell you that, it was a damn near must have. There are even after market expansion packs that have MOAR ram then the official Nintendo one.


    The phantom was a good pick, I'll say that much, but the PS3 disappointment definitely dwarfs the PSP letdown.


    Don't quit your day job.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • aasinko
    aasinko

    7/30/2009 12:08:13 AM

    Oh Wow, who would have figured!

    RT
    www.anon-web-tools.tk

    Reply »
  • Mudbeed
    Mudbeed

    7/29/2009 11:28:41 PM

    Good article for reading. I generally tell people to shut up when they rip on "top" lists but I gotta step in and complain about this, not

    Here it goes. Mode 7 wasnt really that lame (Castlevania 4 used it well) The 64 Ram Pack was free with a game so who cares. PSP go is up to the consumer to buy and made no promises at all (plus it isnt released yet) And pacter? Ughh! Yeah he sucks but who ever believes him anyways?

    Any of the following would have been way better than the 4 I mentioned.

    R.O.B
    Jaguar
    Power Glove
    Virtual Boy
    PSP 3000
    NGage
    Atari 5400
    Konamis Laser Scope Bazooka thingy
    PS EYE or Eyetoy

    I could probably think of more if I tried harder and I know some I mentioned were obvious (which I think you were trying to avoid to be original) but honestly none of the four things you mentioned that I brought up really bothered all that many people...well cept Pacter, but like I said people ignore him anyways.

    Reply »
  • Palalong
    Palalong

    7/29/2009 2:50:41 PM

    I don;t mind the oversights, lord knows if he tried to include them all this article would be huuuuge. Let's not talk about those red vr goggles that you only used on one eye, those things made you queasy as hell

    Reply »
  • CG-Gabe
    CG-Gabe

    7/29/2009 2:18:33 PM

    @dr_anomaly:

    You make me wonder, is Nintendo the best in this category of any company ever? I think so. I mean, you didn't even get to R.O.B. in your list, and they're still trying with the various Wii extras.

    Reply »
  • dr_anomaly
    dr_anomaly

    7/29/2009 12:20:11 PM

    Hilarious! Though there are some obvious oversights. Where is the power glove? It's not too late to make a slot for the "virtual boy". Now that I think about it... this may need to be a reoccurring piece. There is the 3DO, sega gamegear... Yikes, I'd better quit before I get sad.

    Reply »
  • Crispy Specials

  • CG-Prophet
    Game Trust Member
    CG-Prophet (Game Trust Writer)

    7/29/2009 10:46:39 AM

    Excellent list. I don't know that i'd put Pachter at #1 but I have had enough of this guy for a lifetime. But more than that i've had enough of people citing his "predictions" and not following up on it when he's wrong.

    He's the Sylvia Brown of the game industry.

    Reply »

Want a new look on the discussion?
» Take It to the Forums

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post.
0 / 2000 used

Log In and Post

Log In and Post
Xbox 360 | PS3 | Wii | PSP | DS | PC
Crispy Gamer Buyers' Guides

Crispy Gamer
Buyer's Guides


From essential games to must-have accessories, the Game Trust tells you what you need to know about your new gaming system.

Expand Box

© Crispy Gamer, Inc. All rights reserved.

By continuing past this page, and by your continued use of this site,
you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.

Log In or Register with Crispy Gamer

  • Register
  • Log In
  • Facebook
Register
Log In

Use your Facebook account to log in to Crispy Gamer

You'll also be able to add your Facebook friends to Crispy Gamer and post your Crispy Gamer activity in your Facebook feed.

Reasons to Join Crispy Gamer

  • It's Free
  • Leave Comments on Crispy Articles and Blogs
  • Enter Contests and Win Great Prizes
  • Converse With Other Gamers in Our Forums
  • Share What’s Up With Custom Status Text
  • Track Your Activity on Your Personal User Page
  • Chat with Friends in Real-Time