I Call Bullshit: User-Created Conflict

The War for Freedom in Spore

by David Thomas, 6/25/2008 6:03 PM

(Page 1 of 2)

Waiting in line at my local office supply chain superstore, I hear Kurt Cobain's creaky voice from beyond the grave:

"Rape me. Rape me, my friend. Rape me ...."

Ah, the Nirvana classic, so timeless in its despair and desolation that it found its way into the Musak soundtrack of my purchase of file folders. And somehow I could chuckle at the irony of the lyrics superimposed across the incredible blandness of Office Depot, wondering how a song like this slipped into the censorship-happy mainstream of America.

Spore Penis Creature
Tim Edwards of PC Gamer claims Spore's first penis creature.
And it made me that much more annoyed at EA and their double-talk about the freedom of user-created content -- as long as it is squeaky clean, safe and sanitized user-created content.

Yes, I'm talking about the great Spore ban.

The whole story goes like this. EA releases the Spore Creature Creator to build anticipation for the ultimate sandbox game's arrival this September. Fans flock to the software and pump out over a half-million unique critters in the first two days of its release. Demonstrating the staggering variety that life can take, some of these beasties looked like penises. Some actually had a penis. Some had really large penises. And a surprising number of creatures looked an awful lot like two Dr. Suess characters copulating. Cute, crass and kind of creepy. EA responded by banning accounts and culling the herd.

Way to go EA.

Boobalicious
PC Gamer's Kristen Salvatore responds with the very naughty Boobalicious.
Did you forget what you had posted on the Spore Web site:

"With Spore, anyone can be creative -- make whatever you can imagine with easy built-in Creator tools. Then create and guide your unique personal creature on an epic journey of discovery."

Yes, you can make whatever you like as long as that thing is a Tribble with fangs or an animal that looks like a chair. And if you actually make a creature with anything close to naughty bits, then your "epic journey of discovery" is a cease and desist letter from EA legal.

Nice Spore
This is your standard Spore creature. Cute, polite and don't ask how it makes babies.
I know, I know. EA is a mainstream brand and Spore wants to be a mainstream success. These days, this means no sex.

I'm sure this is what my mom had in mind when, as a child, I was having a grand time making my two "Planet of the Apes" action figures kiss, and she shrieked and made me stop and promise never to do that again. Over the years, this ban really didn't do much to help me understand homosexuality and did leave me with an ongoing fascination with man-on-man monkey love.

As it turns out, you can't stop people from thinking about things like sex. All you can do is get them to pretend that they don't, which is more ironic than Grunge classics being played in the stapler aisle.

Spore Two
Since this is actually only one animal, this does give a new meaning to "go f*** yourself."
This bugs me all the more when it comes to Spore. The whole point of Spore is freedom. Making the HippoPenisMus might be juvenile, and maybe you can keep it safely away from EA's searching Sauron eye of censorship by choosing not to upload the beast to the global Sporeapedia. But what's the fun in that? How does that give you the sense of freedom and possibility that Spore promises? By the time the game launches, there might be 50 million different alien races created by players to populate the Spore galaxy -- and not a single one of them will have recognizable genitalia? Since when did the image of God manifest as Mr. Rogers at a Focus on the Family book burning rally?

« Prev  1  2  Next »  

Comments

  • Sep 9 2008 3:02PM

    Ah, Scrubs... Bitter Gamer Groupies is two doors down. Dave brings up a few interesting points and how things 'evolve' and assimilate over time. By the way, Pokemon is hailed as a demonic toy by the ultra-right because they introduce evolution to children as well as the occult in calling for special powers. http://www.carm.org/features/pokemon.htm So, I can't wait for them to start on Spore...one can only imagine the wails of horror and gnashing of the teeth by the Fundamentalists.

  • DavidThomas
    DavidThomas

    Aug 5 2008 6:10PM

    Uh, right. Maybe I was brought up wrong, but cartoon weiners don't actually upset me. But let's back up a step: My argument is pretty simple--you shouldn't promise one thing and do another. That's how I was brought up--to believe in being honest. And really, this isn't a hard problem to solve. A content rating system would let you run a happy Disney universe while I ran one filled with really really wierd stuff. My universe would be more like the real world, with red-assed baboons,

  • Scrubs123
    Scrubs123

    Aug 4 2008 10:30AM

    I must say David Thomas, you seem as though you are just angry at the world. Oh I'm sorry that maxis doesn't want a thousand penises walking around there whole game. I think that they should be banned. Frankly because it bans stupid people like you from playing the game.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to comment.
0 / 500 used
No Crispy Gamer account? Register Now
Email
Password
Remember me at this computer
Filed Under: Spore, user-created content, I Call Bullshit, User-Created Conflict, censorship, Boobalicious, Sporn
  • Bookmark It:
  • Add This Page to Digg
  • Add This Page to Del.ico.us
  • Add This Page to StumbleUpon
  • Add This Page to Technorati
  • Add This Page to Slashdot

» The Game Trust » Columns RSS Feed

Game Action

Most Active Groups

  • WTF DO We Do Now? (406 Topics)

    454 Members | Updated: 10/14/2008
    WTF DO We Do Now? If you are not sure what group to be in and don't like heavy r...
  • Super Smash Bros. Brawl (223 Topics)

    345 Members | Updated: 10/14/2008
    A forum for discussion of the game to end all games, Super Smash Bros. Brawl. T...
  • .;~*] gamer girls [*~:. (112 Topics)

    198 Members | Updated: 10/14/2008
    we are all out there. lets get to know each other (now more moderated than befo...
  • Ryches trivia corner (22 Topics)

    24 Members | Updated: 10/14/2008
    Answer questions for fun.You get the answer right you get to ask the next questi...
  • Graveyard Shift (50 Topics)

    75 Members | Updated: 10/14/2008
    For those of us more active at night,to talk about whatever .

© Crispy Gamer, Inc. All rights reserved.

By continuing past this page, and by your continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.